Reasons Why You May Not Have a Credit Score – Credit Countdown

Reasons Why You May Not Have a Credit Score - PinterestWe’ve written before about the problem of credit invisibility, which is when a consumer does not have a credit score. Millions of consumers are credit invisible in the United States, which represents a serious obstacle in the path to financial success in a society where credit is interwoven with so many aspects of our lives. You yourself may even be credit invisible and looking for a way to become credit visible by gaining credit history.

If you do not have a credit score, credit expert John Ulzheimer explained why this may be the case in a recent Credit Countdown video on the TradelineSupply Company, LLC YouTube channel. Keep reading for the text version or scroll to the bottom of this article to see the video.

What Are the Minimum Credit Scoring Criteria?

In order to be able to generate a credit score, your credit report has to meet certain requirements. These requirements are slightly different depending on whether the credit scoring model being used is a FICO score or a VantageScore.

FICO Score Minimum Credit Scoring Criteria

You must have at least one undisputed tradeline.

A tradeline is an account on your credit report. This may include credit cards, lines of credit, installment loans, etc. (Other items on your credit report that are not accounts and therefore are not considered tradelines include collections, judgments, tax liens, bankruptcies, and inquiries.)

In order to be included by credit scoring models, the tradeline cannot be disputed.

The undisputed tradeline must be at least six months old.

At least six months of credit history are needed in order to accurately predict your likelihood of defaulting in the future, which is what credit scores are designed to do. Trying to come up with a credit score using fewer data points might cause the score to be less predictive of your actual credit risk, which could create problems for lenders.

You must have recent activity on your credit report (within the past six months).

To meet this requirement, you must have at least one undisputed tradeline that has been updated within the past six months. Don’t worry, this can be the same tradeline that qualifies you for the prior two criteria as long as it has reported activity within the past six months, or it can be a different account.

You cannot be listed as “deceased” on your credit report.

Credit scores cannot be created for individuals who are deceased (or appear to be deceased due to an error).

If your credit profile satisfies these criteria, then you will be able to qualify for any FICO score regardless of which generation it may be.

VantageScore Minimum Credit Scoring Criteria

Compared to FICO scores, the VantageScore credit scoring models have less stringent requirements on who can qualify for a credit score.

You cannot be listed as “deceased” on your credit report.

Like FICO scores, VantageScores also do not calculate credit scores for deceased consumers.

You should have at least one or two months of credit history with any credit bureau.

According to MoneyCrashers.com, “the VantageScore model typically produces scores for consumers with one to two months of credit history, regardless of which bureau reports that activity.” The account or accounts do not need to have six months of age in order to be scored.

The company claims that the VantageScore 4.0 and 3.0 models can provide credit scores to 40 million consumers who cannot be scored using other types of credit scoring models since it is easier for consumers with limited information in their credit files to meet the minimum scoring criteria.

What the Lender Sees When You Do Not Have a Credit Score

If a lender tries to pull your credit score and you do not have one for any of the above reasons, they will instead receive what is known as a “reject code” or a “failure code.” 

This reject code indicates to the lender that you have failed to meet the minimum credit scoring criteria and which criteria you did not satisfy.

Watch the video on this topic featuring seasoned credit professional John Ulzheimer below, or go to our YouTube channel to subscribe and see more credit-related videos!

Read more: tradelinesupply.com

Read more

Reasons Why You May Not Have a Credit Score

Reasons Why You May Not Have a Credit Score - PinterestWe’ve written before about the problem of credit invisibility, which is when a consumer does not have a credit score. Millions of consumers are credit invisible in the United States, which represents a serious obstacle in the path to financial success in a society where credit is interwoven with so many aspects of our lives. You yourself may even be credit invisible and looking for a way to become credit visible by gaining credit history.

If you do not have a credit score, credit expert John Ulzheimer explained why this may be the case in a recent Credit Countdown video on the TradelineSupply Company, LLC YouTube channel. Keep reading for the text version or scroll to the bottom of this article to see the video.

What Are the Minimum Credit Scoring Criteria?

In order to be able to generate a credit score, your credit report has to meet certain requirements. These requirements are slightly different depending on whether the credit scoring model being used is a FICO score or a VantageScore.

FICO Score Minimum Credit Scoring Criteria

You must have at least one undisputed tradeline.

A tradeline is an account on your credit report. This may include credit cards, lines of credit, installment loans, etc. (Other items on your credit report that are not accounts and therefore are not considered tradelines include collections, judgments, tax liens, bankruptcies, and inquiries.)

In order to be included by credit scoring models, the tradeline cannot be disputed.

The undisputed tradeline must be at least six months old.

At least six months of credit history are needed in order to accurately predict your likelihood of defaulting in the future, which is what credit scores are designed to do. Trying to come up with a credit score using fewer data points might cause the score to be less predictive of your actual credit risk, which could create problems for lenders.

You must have recent activity on your credit report (within the past six months).

To meet this requirement, you must have at least one undisputed tradeline that has been updated within the past six months. Don’t worry, this can be the same tradeline that qualifies you for the prior two criteria as long as it has reported activity within the past six months, or it can be a different account.

You cannot be listed as “deceased” on your credit report.

Credit scores cannot be created for individuals who are deceased (or appear to be deceased due to an error).

If your credit profile satisfies these criteria, then you will be able to qualify for any FICO score regardless of which generation it may be.

VantageScore Minimum Credit Scoring Criteria

Compared to FICO scores, the VantageScore credit scoring models have less stringent requirements on who can qualify for a credit score.

You cannot be listed as “deceased” on your credit report.

Like FICO scores, VantageScores also do not calculate credit scores for deceased consumers.

You should have at least one or two months of credit history with any credit bureau.

According to MoneyCrashers.com, “the VantageScore model typically produces scores for consumers with one to two months of credit history, regardless of which bureau reports that activity.” The account or accounts do not need to have six months of age in order to be scored.

The company claims that the VantageScore 4.0 and 3.0 models can provide credit scores to 40 million consumers who cannot be scored using other types of credit scoring models since it is easier for consumers with limited information in their credit files to meet the minimum scoring criteria.

What the Lender Sees When You Do Not Have a Credit Score

If a lender tries to pull your credit score and you do not have one for any of the above reasons, they will instead receive what is known as a “reject code” or a “failure code.” 

This reject code indicates to the lender that you have failed to meet the minimum credit scoring criteria and which criteria you did not satisfy.

Watch the video on this topic featuring seasoned credit professional John Ulzheimer below, or go to our YouTube channel to subscribe and see more credit-related videos!

Read more: tradelinesupply.com

Read more

The Top 3 Credit Myths That Won’t Go Away – Credit Countdown With Credit Expert John Ulzheimer

Top 3 Credit Myths - PinterestMyths about credit, unfortunately, are extremely common, even among people who purport to repair credit. We’ve previously compiled a list of common credit myths, which you can find in our Knowledge Center.

In this post, we’re going to focus on the top three credit myths that just won’t seem to go away, according to credit expert John Ulzheimer in a Credit Countdown video on the topic. Check out the video version at the end of this post.

Myth 1: Your revolving utilization ratio is worth 30% of your credit score.

While the general category of how much debt you owe does contribute 30% of your FICO score, the specific metrics regarding revolving utilization are just part of that category, not the whole thing. There are several other metrics included in this category, which FICO lists on their website. These include:

The total amount you owe on all of your credit accounts.
The amounts you owe on different types of accounts, such as installment loans and credit cards.
The number of your accounts that have balances on them.
The ratio of how much you still owe on your installment accounts, such as auto loans and student loans.

Therefore, your revolving utilization must necessarily be worth less than 30% of your credit score, although it is true that it is a highly valuable metric.

Myth 2: Closing an old credit card means the age of the card no longer counts toward your credit score.

Prominent sources in the credit arena often advise consumers not to close their oldest credit cards, claiming that this will cause consumers to lose the benefit of the card’s age. In theory, this idea makes sense because your credit age is worth 15% of your credit score and it is directly connected to your payment history, which is worth an additional 35% of your score.

However, the problem with this advice is that you actually do not lose the age of a credit card once you close the account. In fact, according to John, credit cards continue to increase in age and contribute to your average age of accounts even after they have been closed.

Still, it is important to remember that closing a credit card is not completely free of consequence. When you close a credit card account, you no longer get the benefit of the unused credit limit that was associated with the account, which was likely helping your credit score.

Myth 3: Employers can check your credit scores.

In truth, this myth likely exists because employers can check your credit reports, but credit reports and credit scores are not the same thing. Your credit report contains information about your credit accounts, while your credit score is a three-digit number that represents how creditworthy you are deemed to be by the credit scoring model.

Furthermore, the credit reports that employers receive are different from the versions that are provided to lenders, and these credit reports do not come with credit scores.

 

If there are other credit myths you think we should cover, leave a comment on this article or the accompanying video on our YouTube channel!

Read more: tradelinesupply.com

Read more

Things Everyone Should Know About Credit Cards

Things Everyone Should Know About Credit Cards - Pinterest graphicCredit cards are not only a useful payment method for making purchases but also an essential component of a solid credit-building strategy

After all, credit cards are the most common form of revolving credit, which is given more importance than installment credit (e.g. auto loans, student loans, mortgages, etc.) when it comes to calculating your credit score.

Unfortunately, credit cards often get a bad rap because it’s easy to rack up excessive amounts of debt and destroy your credit score if you do not know how to use credit cards properly.

However, when you have the knowledge and ability to use credit cards to your advantage rather than to your detriment, they can be an extremely powerful financial tool to have in your arsenal.

If you’re unsure if using credit cards is the right choice for you or confused about how they work, then keep reading to learn the basics of credit cards that everyone should know.

What Is a Credit Card?

A credit card is a card issued by a lender that allows a consumer to borrow money from the lender in order to pay for purchases.

The consumer must later pay back the funds in addition to any applicable interest charges or other fees.

They can choose to either pay back the full amount borrowed by the due date, in which case no interest will be charged, or they can pay off the debt over a longer period of time, in which case interest will generally accrue on the unpaid balance.

Each credit card has an account number, a security code, and an expiration date, as well as a magnetic stripe, a signature panel, and a hologram. Most credit cards also now have a chip to be inserted into a chip reader rather than swiping the card at the point of sale. In addition, some credit cards offer contactless payment capability.

Credit cards allow consumers to pay for goods and services with funds borrowed from the credit card issuer.

Credit cards allow consumers to pay for goods and services with funds borrowed from the credit card issuer.

How Do Credit Cards Work?

Although using credit cards may feel like using “fake money” or spending someone else’s money, it’s important to understand that the money you borrow when you pay with a credit card is very much real money that you now owe to the lender.

Credit Cards Are Unsecured Revolving Debt

With most credit cards, the funds you borrow are considered to be unsecured debt because you are borrowing the money without any collateral. That means the credit card issuer is taking on additional risk by giving you a credit card, since there is no collateral that they can take from you if you fail to pay back the debt, unlike with secured debt, such as a mortgage or a car loan.

Furthermore, the lender allows you to decide when and how much you want to pay back the funds instead of requiring you to pay the full balance on each due date. You can choose to only pay the minimum payment and “revolve” the remaining balance from month to month, which extends the amount of time during which you owe money to the credit card company.

Most credit cards now come with a chip in addition to a magnetic stripe.

Most credit cards now come with a chip in addition to a magnetic stripe.

For the above reasons, credit card interest rates are typically significantly higher than the interest rates for installment loans.

However, credit cards are also the only form of credit where paying interest is optional—there is a “grace period” of at least 21 days before the interest rate for new purchases takes effect, and you only get charged interest if you do not pay back your full statement balance by the due date.

(Keep in mind that the grace period usually only applies to new purchases, as stated by The Balance. This does not include balance transfers or cash advances, which typically begin accruing interest immediately.)

Understanding Credit Card Interest Rates

To reiterate, the interest rate of a credit card technically only applies when you carry a balance instead of paying off your full statement balance each month. However, most people will likely end up carrying a balance on one or more credit cards at some point, so it is still a good idea to be aware of what your interest rates are.

APR and ADPR

The interest rate of a credit card is usually expressed as an annual percentage rate (APR). This is the percentage that you would pay in interest over a year, which can be confusing because interest on credit card purchases is charged on a daily basis when you carry a balance from month to month.

You can find your average daily periodic rate (ADPR), which is the interest rate that you are being charged each day, by dividing the APR of your card by 365.

Average Credit Card Interest Rates
The interest rate of a credit card, expressed as the APR, is important to know if you ever carry a balance on the card.

The interest rate of a credit card, expressed as the APR, is important to know if you ever carry a balance on the card.

As of October 2020, the average credit card interest rate as reported by The Balance is 20.23%. However, credit card issuers are allowed to set their APRs as high as 29.99%. It is not uncommon to see APRs upwards of 20%, even for consumers who have good credit.

The highest interest rates are generally seen on credit cards for bad credit or penalty rates that credit card issuers can implement when you are 30 or more days late to make a payment. You may also get penalized with a higher interest rate if you go over your credit limit or default on a different account with the same bank, according to ValuePenguin.

Ask for a Lower Interest Rate

In our article on easy credit hacks that actually work, we suggest trying the simple tactic of calling your credit card issuer’s customer service department and asking for a lower APR. Surveys have shown that a majority of consumers who do this are successful in obtaining a lower interest rate.

Important Dates to Know

Many consumers assume that the payment due date of your credit card is the only important date you need to worry about. While it’s true that the due date is the most important date to be aware of, there are several other dates that are useful to pay attention to as well.

Billing cycle

The billing cycle of a credit card is the length of time that passes between one billing statement and the next. All of the purchases you make within one billing cycle are grouped together in the following billing statement.

This cycle is typically around 30 days long, or approximately monthly, although credit card companies can choose to use a different billing cycle system.

Statement closing date
Your credit card's statement closing date is not the same thing as your due date, so make sure you know both.

Your credit card’s statement closing date is not the same thing as your due date, so make sure you know both.

Sometimes referred to simply as the “closing date,” this is the final day of your billing cycle. Once a billing cycle closes and the statement for that cycle is generated, the balance of your account at that time is then reported to the credit bureaus.

You can look at your billing statement to find the closing date for your account. Because of the 21-day grace period, the statement closing date is usually around 21 days before your due date.

Due Date

This is the most important date to know in order to pay your bill on time every month, which is the most influential factor when it comes to building a good credit history. To make it easy for yourself to avoid accidental missed payments, you may want to set up automatic bill payments.

If your due date is inconvenient due to the timing of your income and other bills, you can try requesting a different due date with your credit card issuer.

Promotional offer dates

Many credit cards offer introductory promotions to attract new customers, such as 0% APR, bonus rewards, or no balance transfer fees. To use these offers strategically, you will need to know when the promotional period ends so you can plan accordingly.

Expiration date
All credit cards have an expiration date past which they cannot be used.

All credit cards have an expiration date past which they cannot be used.

Every credit card has an expiration date printed on it, after which you will no longer be able to use that card, although your account will still be open. You just have to get a new credit card sent to you to replace the one that is expiring.

Usually, credit card companies will automatically send you a new card before the original card expires. If this does not happen, simply call the issuer to ask for a replacement credit card.

A Common Credit Card Mistake

Some consumers think that the closing date and the due date are the same thing and therefore believe that if they pay off the full statement balance by the due date, the credit card will report as having a 0% utilization ratio. They may then be confused to find out that their credit card is still reporting a balance to the credit bureaus every month.

However, the statement closing date is usually not the same date as your due date. This is why your credit cards may report a balance every month even if you always pay your bill in full—the account balance is being recorded on your statement date before you have paid off the card.

If you do not want your credit card to report a balance to the credit bureaus, you will need to either pay off the balance early, prior to the statement closing date, or pay your statement balance on the due date as usual and then not make any more purchases with your card until the next closing date.

Credit Card Payments

With credit cards, you have several different options for payment amounts.

Minimum payment
If you make only the minimum payments on your credit cards, it will take you longer to pay off your credit card debt and you will be charged interest.

If you only pay the minimum payments on your credit cards, it will take longer to pay off your credit card debt and you will be charged interest.

This is the minimum amount that you are required to pay by your due date in order to be considered current on the account and avoid late fees. Although this may vary between different credit card issuers, typically the minimum payment is calculated as a percentage of your balance.

If you make only the minimum payment every month, it will take you a much longer time to pay off your balance and you will be paying a far greater amount in interest than if you were to pay off your statement balance in full. Check your billing statement to see how the math works out; the credit card company is required to disclose how long it will take to pay off the balance if you only make the minimum payments.

Statement balance

This is the sum of all of your charges from the preceding billing cycle in addition to whatever balance may have already been on the card before that cycle. This is the amount you need to pay if you do not want to pay interest for carrying a balance.

Current balance

This number is the total balance currently on your credit card, including charges made during the billing cycle that you are currently in, so it will be higher than your statement balance if you have made more purchases or transfers since your last closing date. You can pay this amount if you want to completely pay off your account so that it has no balance.

Other amount

You can also make a payment in the amount of your choosing, as long as it is greater than the minimum payment. This is a good option to use if you don’t have enough cash to pay the statement balance in full, but want to pay more than the minimum in order to mitigate the amount of interest you will be charged.

Credit Card Fees

Credit cards often charge various other fees in addition to interest. Here are some common fees to be aware of.

Although you may have access to a "cash advance" credit limit on your credit cards, it is generally not recommended to get a cash advance due to the high interest rates and fees you will have to pay.

Although you may have access to a “cash advance” credit limit on your credit cards, it is generally not recommended to get a cash advance due to the high interest rates and fees you will have to pay.

Late payment fees

If you do not make the required minimum payment before the due date, the credit card company will likely charge you a late fee somewhere in the range of $25 – $40 (in addition to potentially raising your APR to a penalty rate). If you usually pay on time but accidentally miss a payment for whatever reason, try calling your credit card issuer and asking if they would be willing to reverse the fee since you have been an upstanding customer overall.

Annual fees

Some credit cards charge an annual fee for keeping your account open. Many times this charge may be waived for your first year as a promotional offer to attract new customers. Cards with higher annual fees will often have additional perks and rewards, but there are also plenty of great options for rewards cards that do not charge annual fees.

Cash advance fees

Your credit cards may give you the option to borrow cash in the form of a cash advance. However, this is usually not advised because cash advance interest rates are often significantly higher than your regular interest rate for purchases. In addition, you will most likely be charged a cash advance fee when you first withdraw the money, whether a flat dollar amount of around $10 or a percentage of the amount you take out, such as 5%.

Foreign transaction fees

Some cards charge a fee to use your card to pay for things in other countries. These fees are typically around 3% of the purchase amount. However, there are many credit cards on the market that do not charge foreign transaction fees.

Be sure to check the terms of service of your credit cards for fees such as these so that you can avoid any unexpected charges.

How Credit Cards Affect Your Credit

Credit cards are one of the most impactful influences on your overall credit standing, and they play a role in multiple credit scoring factors.

Building Credit With Credit Cards

One of the major advantages of credit cards is that it allows you to start building a history of on-time payments, which is extremely important given that payment history is the biggest component of your FICO score, making up 35% of it.

All you have to do to get this benefit is use your credit card every so often and pay your bill on time every month.

Click on the infographic to see the full-sized version!

Click on the infographic to see the full-sized version!

Revolving Accounts Are More Important

We have previously discussed why revolving accounts are more powerful than installment accounts when it comes to your credit score.

Revolving accounts such as credit cards can have a much greater influence on your credit than auto loans, student loans, and even a mortgage—for better or for worse. They must be managed properly because negative credit card accounts will also have a very strong impact on your credit.

Mix of Credit

Although your mix of credit only makes up 10% of your FICO score, it is still worth considering, especially if you aim to achieve a high credit score or even a perfect 850 credit score.

A good credit mix generally includes various types of accounts, including both revolving and installment accounts. You can see the different types of accounts in our credit mix infographic.

Credit cards may help with your credit mix if you have a thin file or if you primarily have installment loans on your credit report.

They also add to the number of accounts you have, which is a good thing for the average consumer. In fact, as we talked about in How to Get an 850 Credit Score, FICO has stated that those who have high FICO scores have an average of seven credit card accounts in their credit files, whether open or closed.

The Importance of Credit Utilization Ratios

Your credit utilization is the second most important piece of your credit score, which is another reason why credit cards are such a strong influence on your credit.

The basic rule of thumb with credit utilization ratios is to try to keep them as low as possible (both overall and individual utilization ratios), meaning you only use a small portion of your available credit. Ideally, it’s best to aim to stay under 20% or even 10% utilization, because the higher your utilization rate is, the more it will hurt your credit instead of help.

Conclusions on Credit Card Basics

Credit cards can be intimidating, especially when you don’t know how to use them correctly.

It is also true that not everyone wants or needs to use credit cards.

It’s not impossible to build credit without a credit card, but it is more difficult since you would be limited to primarily installment loans, which are not weighed as heavily as revolving accounts, and possibly alternative credit data.

However, for those who are able to use credit cards responsibly and follow good credit practices, they can be an incredibly useful credit-building tool as well as a way to reap some benefits and perks that other payment methods do not provide.

We hope this introductory guide to credit cards provides the knowledge base you need in order to feel confident using credit cards and to take advantage of their benefits.

If you found this article useful, please comment to let us know or share it with others who want to learn more about credit cards!

Read more: tradelinesupply.com

Read more

What Happened to Equal Credit Opportunity for All?

What Happened to Equal Credit Opportunity for All? - Pinterest graphic

Equality, fairness, and justice are all concepts that the United States promotes as some of its highest values.

In reality, the history of our country and society has not always lived up to those values. In fact, our history has proven to be so far from those ideals that we do not even need to mention how far off our society has been in our not so distant past.

Fast forward to now, and many people may believe that our country has worked out all those unfair and unequal practices. But the truth is that in our capitalist society, powerful private institutions provide the backbone of our economy, and the facts paint an interesting picture of how our financial systems really operate.

Do Credit Scores Actually Work?

For decades, lenders have been relying on automated underwriting tools that are largely or entirely based on the contents of one’s credit report. Do these tools succeed at their goal of accurately determining the creditworthiness of consumers?

What Do Credit Scores Do?

A credit score is a number that is supposed to symbolize the credit risk of a consumer. The scale usually ranges from 300 to 850, with lower scores indicating that you have a high risk of defaulting on a loan and higher scores indicating that you have a low risk of defaulting. Generally, credit scores that fall below 579 are considered bad credit, while scores that exceed 670 are considered good credit, and 850 is a perfect credit score.

Each type of credit score, such as a FICO Score or a VantageScore, has a different mathematical formula that uses the data in your credit report to produce your score, which represents the statistical likelihood of you defaulting in the future. The specifics of the credit scoring algorithms are trade secrets, so information about how exactly they work is not available to the public.

Credit Scoring Models Are Flawed

It is estimated that one-fifth of consumers have at least one error on their credit report that has the potential to make them look riskier than they are, which could result in higher interest rates, less favorable loan terms, or being denied credit. In other words, millions of people are negatively affected by inaccurate information on their credit reports.

Furthermore, it is well-known that in our credit system, consumers are rewarded for having debt and penalized for paying in cash, because taking on debt is one of the primary ways of establishing a payment history. You would think that being burdened with more debt would make you a higher credit risk, yet credit scoring models are designed to reward this behavior.

For example, many consumers are unpleasantly surprised to find out that sometimes paying off a loan can actually hurt your credit score. This is counterintuitive because it would seem that your credit risk has decreased now that you no longer have to make payments that loan, and therefore it would make sense for your credit score to go up as a result.

However, that is not how credit scores work. Here’s what really happens in this scenario: the action of paying off the loan would close the account and remove it from your mix of credit, which could have a negative effect on your score.

Clark Abrahams, Chief Financial Architect of SAS Institute, said it well in his testimony before the House Financial Services Committee, asking, “Are we to tell consumers that being responsible in their financial affairs means that they need to modify their behavior so as to maximize their credit score?”

The goal of a credit score is to indicate who is creditworthy and who is not, which should depend on an individual’s ability and willingness to repay an obligation. Yet this quality is not always reflected in one’s credit score. Instead, credit scores are based exclusively on what is and is not in one’s credit file, which often doesn’t tell the whole story.

Is the Credit Scoring System Fair and Equitable?

Credit score

Just a few years ago, it was revealed that two of the three major credit-reporting agencies that control credit scores—Equifax and Transunion—had been deceiving and taking advantage of consumers.

If you’re familiar with the credit system, it’s not exactly shocking that the credit bureaus have been abusing their power. This is just one example of the dysfunction that runs deep in the credit system and causes widespread harm to consumers.

The Equal Credit Opportunity Act of 1974 was enacted in an effort to prevent discrimination in lending. In the 1970’s, people started to pay attention to credit discrimination against consumers based on age, race, gender, and other factors. In 1972, the National Commission on Consumer Finance revealed that there was widespread discrimination against women in the credit industry. A congressional report identified 13 discriminatory practices used specifically against women.

These discoveries led to the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA), which prohibits lenders from discriminating against any applicant on the basis of age, gender, ethnicity, nationality, or marital status. Regulation B of ECOA prohibits creditors from requesting information about certain characteristics to prevent lenders from making decisions based on prejudicial assumptions.

Officially, credit discrimination is prohibited. But it is not clear whether ECOA has succeeded in its goal, and many questions remain as to whether there is still inequality in the credit industry.

Is ECOA enforced effectively, or does discrimination still happen? Does the credit scoring system affect population groups differently? Do the factors used in calculating credit scores affect certain individuals grouped by race, gender, age, or other protected characteristics?

Unfortunately, the language of ECOA makes it virtually impossible for those who believe they have been discriminated against to win a lawsuit against a creditor, and the governing federal agencies have not picked up the slack in enforcing ECOA. There is no shortage of data showing that there is disparate treatment of certain groups when it comes to credit scoring.

This is because the credit scoring system not only reflects but perpetuates the economic inequalities in this country.

Who Are Credit Invisibles?

According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), about one-fifth of adults in the United States are “credit invisible,” meaning they are unscoreable by traditional credit scoring methods and traditional credit data. The lack of a conventional credit record prevents these consumers from obtaining the financial products and services they need to be successful, since they are seen by lenders as too high of a credit risk.

A study by the Policy and Economic Research Council (PERC) on credit invisibility in Silicon Valley showed that unscoreability is a big problem in low-income areas. However, low-income does not necessarily equate to financially irresponsible.

We can see evidence of this in a study by PERC and the Brookings Institution Urban Markets Initiative, which shows that when alternative data (such as rent and utility payment history) are used in credit ratings, those lacking a traditional credit history have similar risk profiles as those in the credit mainstream. This suggests that most credit invisible consumers do not represent a high risk to lenders.

On the other hand, some of these consumers do have relatively good incomes, but are credit invisible for various reasons, such as increased use of alternative financial technology services instead of traditional financial institutions, a decision to be voluntarily credit-inactive and debt-free, or a cash-based lifestyle due to lack of access to banking services (as in some immigrant populations).

Credit Scores and Income

Credit scores adversely affect certain groups

Low-income consumers are about 8 times more likely than high-income consumers to lack credit records that are scoreable by widely used models. In consumers that do have credit scores, individuals who reside in low-income census tracts have lower credit scores than other income groups, according to the CFPB.

They also found that people in lower-income neighborhoods are less than half as likely as those in upper-income neighborhoods to gain a credit record by relying on the good credit of others (such as through joint accounts or authorized user accounts), and are 240 percent more likely to become credit visible due to negative records.

Lower-income consumers are less likely to have one or more AU accounts, and those that do acquire shorter credit histories from the accounts than those in higher-income areas.

Even after controlling for credit scores, consumers in low-income areas face higher denial rates than other groups.

How Credit Scoring Adversely Affects Certain Races

In a report to Congress on credit scoring and its effects on the availability and affordability of credit, the Federal Reserve Board (FRB) raised concerns that factors in credit-scoring models could adversely affect minorities.

The study determined that on average, blacks and Hispanics have lower credit scores than non-Hispanic whites and Asians, and a gap remained even when controlling for differences in personal demographic characteristics, location, and income.

In addition, for given credit scores, outcomes such as loan performance, credit availability, and credit affordability differed between these groups.

For example, it seems that black individuals pay higher interest rates on auto and installment loans than do non-Hispanic whites with the same credit score. In addition, black and Hispanic consumers experience higher denial rates than other groups with the same score.

Credit Scoring Discriminates by Age

Equal credit opportunity for all

Younger individuals tend to have lower credit scores, which makes sense considering that one of the main factors in credit scoring is the length of credit history.

Unfortunately, this means that young people who may be creditworthy are disadvantaged just by virtue of not being old enough to have a very long credit history. Younger consumers also experience relatively high denial rates.

Other Groups Marginalized by Credit Rating

The unequal effects of credit scoring are not limited to the above groups. It can affect consumers in surprising ways. For example, recent immigrants have lower credit scores than their performance would predict.

Credit invisibility is more prevalent in areas with less digital access to traditional financial service providers, such as in rural areas.

And since no federal law protects LGBTQ people from discrimination, they can still be denied credit with no option for recourse.

Why the Credit System Is Inherently Discriminatory

In the FRB’s report to Congress, they listed the “five C’s,” which are factors that seem to influence the variations in credit performance with race, age, gender, national origin, etc. The five C’s are:

Capacity: income available to pay off debts
Collateral: the value of assets backing a loan
Capital: the value of assets that do not explicitly back a loan but may be available to repay it
Conditions: events that can disrupt income generation or create unexpected expenses that affect a borrower’s ability to make loan payments
Character: the financial skills, experience, and/or willingness of a borrower that pertain to their ability to manage financial obligations

The way credit scores are determined privileges those who already have wealth, high incomes, education, and a support system of people who can help them out in a financial crisis.

In contrast, historical discrimination against minorities in the United States continues to affect each of the five C’s in ways that have serious and persistent consequences on credit scores.

In relying on and reflecting past inequality, credit scores also perpetuate that inequality.

According to the National Consumer Law Center, communities of color have less income and far less wealth than white Americans, thanks to centuries of discrimination and exclusion. Redlining, segregation in education, implicit bias in employment, and mass incarceration have prevented communities of color from attaining higher incomes and accumulating wealth.

The racial wealth gap makes it exponentially more difficult to recover from emergencies or financial setbacks. These inequalities take a toll on each of the 5 C’s, which in turn contributes to the higher proportion of credit invisibility and poor credit in minority communities.

Since credit scores are used in decisions that affect housing, insurance, employment, loans and more, poor credit scores mean consumers of color are disproportionately denied credit, affordable housing, jobs and other basic necessities. Expensive loan terms deplete capital and make loans much more difficult to repay, which continues the cycle of bad credit.

The system further burdens those who are already financially strained and provides very few opportunities to improve their situation.

Can We Fix Credit Scoring?

The credit scoring industry clearly has a multitude of problems. It’s no surprise that an inherently discriminatory system meant to serve for-profit companies has not produced equitable results.

Some believe that private companies shouldn’t even be the parties responsible for calculating credit scores. These for-profit corporations harvest our information, use closely-guarded proprietary algorithms to calculate credit scores, and sell this information to other companies in the financial sector.

Their clients are lenders, not consumers, so they do not have an incentive to fairly and accurately represent consumers. Perhaps a system in which this task falls to public institutions would be more accountable to consumers.

Pending currently is the Credit Access and Inclusion Act of 2017, a bill that would amend the Fair Credit Reporting Act to allow the reporting of rent, utilities, and telecommunication payment information to consumer reporting agencies. Even FICO has joined the discourse about financial inclusion, developing credit scores that include alternative data sources to allow millions of previously unscorable consumers a path to credit.

However, most lenders still use FICO 8, which is over 10 years old, so it would likely take a long time before scores that draw on more diverse data are widely deployed.

In addition, some civil rights and consumer advocacy groups argue that the addition of alternative data would actually “reduce consumers’ control over their own data by preempting state and federal privacy protections [and] damage the credit scores of millions of consumers with a disproportionate impact on African Americans.”

Perhaps what we really need is a broader conversation about how we judge creditworthiness and how we can create new tools that account for discrimination to create a more equal and just playing field. We need to question the assumption that past behavior is a true reflection of someone’s creditworthiness.

While the industry may be (very) slowly changing for the better, unfortunately, the faulty credit scoring system we have now will continue to negatively impact the lives of millions of people for years to come. That’s why we are driven to help provide solutions and opportunities to disadvantaged consumers.Equal credit opportunity

How Do Tradelines Fit Into Equal Credit Opportunity?

Having good credit often comes down to having a good start in life and knowing how to play the credit game. Some people are born with access to wealth and education while others are not. People who don’t have the resources to start building good credit early on often get stuck in the downward spiral of a broken system that leaves them little room to improve their financial situation.

When people make mistakes, as we all do sometimes, these mistakes have a much greater impact on those who lack good credit than on those who have been playing the credit game for years.

The gap between classes in society is getting larger, as opposed to our country’s ideal of promoting equality. In reality, the wealthy are the ones who receive the most help and opportunity.

Our society has become a credit-based society in which credit scores affect almost every aspect of our lives, yet there are clear “winners” and “losers” in our credit scoring system. Statistically, there are clear indications that these differences are not spread out equally across our country.

Good credit is something that many privileged Americans start out with in early adulthood because of the family they were born into. This is no secret among the wealthy.

On the other end of the spectrum, many lower-income families do not have family members with good credit that they can ask to help them build credit by adding them as an authorized user on a credit card. This option simply does not exist to many, while the banks encourage it for others.

To us, it does not seem fair that some people have this option but others do not. Tradeline Supply Company, LLC seeks to bridge this gap by helping to provide a chance at equal credit opportunity for all.

What do you think about the credit system and equal credit opportunity? If you liked this article, please share it or leave us a comment below!

Read more: tradelinesupply.com

Read more

Questions Every Authorized User Should Ask When Buying Tradelines

Questions Every Authorized User Should Ask When Buying Tradelines - Pin this article!

Buying authorized user tradelines is an investment in your financial future. Make sure you are getting the most out of your tradelines by asking yourself the following questions first.

1. What is my average age of accounts?

Age is one of the most important factors in your credit history, so it is important to understand what your own average age of accounts is and how that metric could be impacting your credit. It will also play a role in determining which tradelines you should add to your account.

Calculating your average age of accounts is easy. Just add together the ages of all of your revolving accounts (e.g. credit cards) and divide this total by the number of accounts.

For example, let’s say we have four accounts and their ages are 2 years, 4 years, 5.5 years, and 6 months. Here’s how we calculate the average age of accounts: 2 years + 4 years + 5.5 years + 0.5 years = 12 years / 4 accounts = 3 years average age of accounts.

You don’t even have to do the math yourself if you use our Tradeline Calculator. Just put your information into the calculator and let it do the work for you.

Use our tradeline calculator to find your average age of accounts and utilization ratios.

Use our tradeline calculator to find your average age of accounts and utilization ratios.

Not sure how old your accounts are? You can pull your own credit report for free (without hurting your score) on websites like Credit Karma.

2. What is my utilization ratio?

Your utilization ratio, or the ratio of the debt you owe to the total credit limit of all your revolving accounts, is another important influence on your credit score to be aware of. Your utilization contributes about 30% of your credit score, so high utilization can drag down credit, even after tradelines are added. Therefore, it’s important to calculate your utilization ratio before buying tradelines.

Here’s how to do it: add up all of the debts you owe on your revolving accounts and then add up all of the credit limits of each of your revolving accounts. Take the total amount that you owe and divide it by your total credit limit to get your ratio.

If you’re not a big fan of math, you can check your utilization ratio and find out how adding new tradelines might affect it using our Tradeline Calculator.

If you have credit cards with high utilization, consider whether paying down the balances might be a good investment before buying tradelines.

If you have credit cards with high utilization, paying down the balances might be a good investment.

3. Do I have any credit cards with high utilization that should be paid off?

Even if your overall utilization is relatively low, individual credit cards with high utilization can still hurt your credit. Adding a tradeline can affect your overall utilization as described above, but will not solve the problem of having one or more cards with high utilization individually.

If you can easily pay down your balances to get the utilization to be 20% or lower, that would be money well spent, because you are lowering your utilization ratios to a level that is considered to be better for your credit.

On the other hand, if the amount that you owe is quite large and you are not in a position to significantly lower your utilization right away, then perhaps getting a couple of high limit tradelines may be the easier route to go.

Either way, utilization ratios are very important and should be taken into consideration when buying tradelines.

A credit freeze or fraud alert will prevent new tradelines from posting to your credit report.

A credit freeze or fraud alert will prevent new tradelines from posting to your credit report.

4. Do I have a credit freeze or fraud alert on my credit report?

A credit freeze or fraud alert will block access your credit file, which prevents any new information from being added to your credit report. Therefore, if you have placed a credit freeze or fraud alert on your credit file, new tradelines will not post.

Be sure to check whether you have a fraud alert or credit freeze before purchasing a tradeline and contact the credit bureaus to remove it if necessary.

5. What is my priority: age or credit limit?

While the length of credit history only makes up about 15% of a score, age also goes hand-in-hand with payment history, which is the most valuable factor in credit scoring. The more age an account has, the more time it has had to accumulate a positive or negative payment history.

All of our tradelines have a perfect payment history, and together, age and payment history make up 50% of a credit score. Therefore, we believe it is better to prioritize age in most circumstances.

However, there are some cases in which people choose to prioritize the credit limit of a tradeline over its age. Be sure to carefully consider your personal situation and what is most important to you.

6. What are the credit limits of the AU tradelines?

If you are buying tradelines from a reputable business, the tradelines should all be from reliable banks, have perfect payment histories, and have low utilization. Since these factors are going to be about the same for each card, the two main things to consider when choosing tradelines are age and credit limit.

The credit limit factor is important because it can affect your overall utilization ratio. While individual cards with high utilization can still have a negative impact on your credit, getting your overall utilization as low as possible can still be very beneficial.

Additionally, depending on your goals, the credit limit can be an important factor if you are trying to establish a history of higher-limit accounts in your credit file.

7. How old are the tradelines?

As we stated previously, the age of a tradeline is extremely valuable, and in most cases, it is more important than the credit limit. This is because a seasoned tradeline will contribute not only to your length of credit history but also add a long period of a perfect payment record.

As we said earlier, these two categories together make up half of your score, far outweighing the other categories. Therefore, a good general rule of thumb is to buy the oldest tradelines your budget allows for.

Another reason you want to go for older tradelines is that tradelines that do not have sufficient age can actually hurt your score by decreasing your average age of accounts.

If your average age of accounts is 3 years, for example, your tradeline should be a minimum of 4 years old, but ideally much higher than that if the goal is to see a significant difference. If you buy a tradeline that is only 2 years old, your average age of accounts will decrease, which could damage your credit score. This is why it’s critical to do the calculations using our Tradeline Calculator before making a purchase.

To determine which tradelines to buy, you will need to think about age as well as credit limit.

To determine which tradelines to buy, you will need to think about age as well as the credit limit. Photo via Hloom.com.

8. Which tradelines should I buy? How do I choose the right tradelines?

Once you have determined what your priorities are, you will be better prepared to choose the right tradelines for you. If you want to increase your average age of accounts or extend the age of your oldest account, go for the older tradelines.

If you are more focused on credit limit or your overall utilization ratio, check out our higher-limit tradelines.

You can view the tradelines we have available and sort the list by age and credit limit on our updated tradeline list. For more guidance on choosing the best tradelines, read our buyer’s guide to tradelines.

9. Do the tradelines have perfect payment histories?

Payment history makes up 35% of a credit score, making it the most important component. It is crucial that any tradelines you add have a perfect payment history, because even one missed payment can do serious damage to your credit. All of our tradelines are guaranteed to have a spotless payment history.

10. Are the tradelines substantially better than what I already have in my file?

Obviously, a tradeline will only be effective for you if it is superior to the other tradelines that are already in your credit file. The safest bet is to look for one that is significantly higher in age and/or credit limit than the accounts that you already have in order to affect your averages as much as possible.

Keep in mind the reporting date and the purchase by date when buying tradelines.

Keep in mind the reporting date and the purchase by date when buying tradelines.

It is difficult to affect an average, especially when there are already several accounts in your credit file, so adding a tradeline that is only marginally better than your existing tradelines may not have the desired effect. Make sure to invest in a high-quality tradeline that has real potential for results rather than just adding more of what you already have.

11. When is the reporting period and when is the purchase by date?

The reporting period of a tradeline is when the bank reports the tradeline to the credit bureaus, which is usually around the same time each billing cycle, with some fluctuation. You should see any new tradelines you purchased on your credit report once their respective reporting periods have passed.

Since processing payments and adding authorized users takes time, there is a “purchase by” date that tradelines must be purchased before if you want them to report in the upcoming reporting period. You can still purchase tradelines after their purchase by date, but keep in mind that they may not post until the next reporting period.

Our tradeline list provides the reporting period and the corresponding purchase by date for each of our tradelines. Be sure to keep these dates in mind when making your purchase.

12. Which banks are the tradelines from?

The bank that the tradeline is from is important because many banks do not accurately report authorized user data to the credit bureaus. The tradeline needs to come from a bank that has proven to report AU data reliably in order to be sure the tradeline has the best chance of posting.

With Tradeline Supply Company, LLC, you do not have to worry about choosing the right banks, because all of the banks we work with have been proven to report reliably to all three major credit bureaus.

However, there is one exception: if you have any outstanding collections or if you have filed bankruptcy with a certain bank, this can prevent your tradelines from posting successfully, so you will want to avoid purchasing tradelines from that bank.

Depending on your situation, you may need multiple tradelines, or just one may be enough.

Depending on your situation, you may need multiple tradelines, but in other situations, just one may be enough.

13. How many tradelines do I need?

Since everyone’s credit file is complex and unique to their situation, it can be difficult to know whether it is best to buy multiple tradelines or one very high-quality tradeline. If there are budget constraints, it is usually most effective to purchase one premium tradeline rather than multiple tradelines that are less powerful.

However, there are other situations in which multiple tradelines might be a better choice.

Just remember that the power of tradelines is always going to be relative to your current credit file. If you are not sure how many tradelines you may need, our article, “Buying Tradelines: How Many Tradelines Do I Need?” can help guide your decision.

14. Does the tradeline company use address merging or work with CPNs?
Watch out for companies engaging in address merging or other types of fraud.

Watch out for companies engaging in address merging or other types of fraud.

Many tradeline companies tell their customers to claim the same address as the primary account holders of the tradelines, even though they do not live there, in order to increase the likelihood of the tradelines posting. Essentially, they are asking their customers to commit fraud and lie about their address.

This illegal tactic is commonly known as “address merging.” If a tradeline company does address merging, all parties involved could be implicated in fraud, so savvy authorized users will want to avoid these unscrupulous companies.

Similarly, companies often sell tradelines for “credit profile numbers” or “credit privacy numbers,” known as CPNs. We have written at length about the dangers of CPNs, but to summarize, using a CPN instead of your real social security number to apply for credit is identity fraud and a felony offense.

Beyond that, so-called CPNs are often SSNs stolen from other people, especially children, which means these companies are involved not only in fraud but also identity theft.

Clearly, a company that is committing fraud by merging addresses or working with CPNs is not one you want to do business with.

15. Do I trust the company providing the tradelines?

The most important part of the process of buying tradelines is being able to trust the company you are working with. After all, you want to be sure you won’t get stuck with tradelines that are low-quality, are overpriced, or don’t post well. Plus, you want to be certain your tradeline company provides secure online transactions and takes extensive measures to prevent fraud. Watch out for unethical and unprofessional tradeline companies, and make sure to choose one that you trust and that will treat you with integrity and respect.

15. When will my tradelines post?
Make sure to choose a tradeline company with integrity that you trust.

Make sure to choose a tradeline company that acts with integrity.

Some tradeline companies say that it could take up to 60 days for your tradelines to report. If you don’t want to wait two months for your tradelines to show up on your credit file, we can get tradelines to post in as few as 11 days, and sometimes even sooner than that.

15. How long will I stay on the tradeline?

Some tradeline companies only keep AUs on their tradelines for a single reporting cycle. This doesn’t give you very much time to accomplish your goals.

Generally, it’s best if you can stay on the tradeline for at least two reporting cycles, which should allow you enough time to accomplish your goals. If you think you might need additional time on the tradeline, ask whether the company offers extensions.

Check what the company’s policy is, and remember that if their standard is just one cycle, keep in mind that you’d have to double the price in order to be on par with companies that keep AUs on for two reporting cycles.

16. What steps can I take to ensure that my tradelines have the best chance of posting?

To minimize the chances of a non-posting occurring, make sure to take the following steps:

Remove all fraud alerts, credit freezes, and credit locks from your credit report, since these block new information from being added to your credit file and therefore prevent tradelines from posting.
Purchase your tradeline no later than the purchase by date shown on our tradeline list.
Consider buying multiple tradelines as a precautionary measure to hedge against potential non-postings.
Only buy tradelines from companies that have high posting success rates and a money-back posting guarantee.
Do not buy tradelines from banks that you have outstanding collection accounts with or have declared bankruptcy with, since you may be blacklisted from working with that bank again.
Use the correct address that you have on file with the credit bureaus so that your identity can be cross-verified with your credit file.
Do not work with companies that conduct “address merging,” which is a form of fraud.
Double-check your order and payment information for accuracy. Typos in your personal information can cause a non-posting and incorrect bank account information can delay payment processing and therefore can delay the tradeline from posting.

You can find more details about these steps in our article, “How to Get Tradelines to Post.” 

 

If you found these questions helpful, or if you have any questions you think we should add to the list, please comment to let us know!

Read more: tradelinesupply.com

Read more